The Life Cycle of Stars
ConfirmedStars burn hydrogen into helium in their cores, and then into heavier elements, and their final fate is determined mainly by their initial mass Confirmed . Stars of intermediate mass, roughly 0.8 to 8 times the mass of the Sun, shed their outer layers at the end of their lives as a planetary nebula, leaving behind a carbon core called a white dwarf. According to the educational materials of the Chandra Observatory, this core does not have enough mass to burn carbon, and its initial temperature is around twenty thousand kelvin, but because it is so small it appears very faint Confirmed .
For stars with a mass greater than about eight times that of the Sun, the end of the story is entirely different. After their nuclear fuel is exhausted, these stars undergo core collapse, and the rebound shock wave scatters their layers into space in a supernova Confirmed . Depending on its mass, the remaining core is either a neutron star or a black hole. The exact boundary between the two at intermediate masses depends on the equation of state of matter at supranuclear densities and is still not known with full precision Open question .
Binary systems play a prominent role here. Many stars live in binary systems, and the transfer of mass between them can alter the course of their evolution; a clear example is a white dwarf that draws matter from its companion and approaches the Chandrasekhar limit. We return to this mechanism in the next section, on Type Ia supernovae. All the elements heavier than hydrogen and helium, from the carbon in our bodies to iron, were made in such processes inside stars and in their explosions, and were returned to the interstellar medium Confirmed .
A distinction must be drawn between what has been observed and what is modeling. The general stages of stellar evolution, from hydrogen burning to the white dwarf and the supernova, have been confirmed by observing stars at various stages and by observing the remnants of explosions Confirmed . But details, such as the effect of rotation and magnetic fields on the core or the exact mass boundary between different outcomes, are still being refined in simulations, and the upper figures should be regarded as approximate Hypothesis .
- 0.8 to 8Approximate mass range of stars that end as white dwarfs (in solar masses)
- More than 8Mass required for core collapse and a core-collapse supernova (solar masses)
- About 20000Initial temperature of a white dwarf (kelvin)
Supernovae, Neutron Stars and Pulsars
ConfirmedSupernovae are divided into two great families. Type Ia is the thermonuclear explosion of a white dwarf in a binary system; when its mass exceeds the Chandrasekhar limit, about 1.4 solar masses, the carbon in the core begins to burn explosively Confirmed . Types II, Ib and Ic arise from the core collapse of massive stars and are distinguished from one another by the elements seen in their spectra. This limit is named after the astrophysicist Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, who was also awarded the Nobel Prize.
Because Type Ia supernovae release nearly the same energy every time, astronomy calls them "standard candles": comparing apparent brightness with intrinsic brightness yields the distance to the host galaxy Confirmed . This very property is the basis of the discovery of the acceleration of cosmic expansion and of the measurement of the Hubble constant, both examined in later sections.
From the 1930s onward, the neutron star was considered theoretically plausible. The discovery of pulsars in 1967 was the first observational evidence: Antony Hewish and his group at the University of Cambridge found radio sources that emitted a regular pulse roughly once every second, and this led to Hewish receiving the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1974, together with Martin Ryle Confirmed . The first signs were noticed in the data by Jocelyn Bell Burnell, his doctoral student; her role has repeatedly been raised in historical discussions about fairness in scientific prizes. The accepted interpretation is that a pulsar is a rotating, strongly magnetized neutron star with a diameter of the order of ten kilometers, which sweeps a beam of radio waves toward Earth like a lighthouse Confirmed .
Supernovae are not merely spectacular explosions; they are both measuring instruments and element factories. Observing a Type Ia supernova in a distant galaxy yields the distance and, when repeated for tens of thousands of samples, the history of cosmic expansion. For this reason, the accuracy of the calibration of these standard candles directly affects the debate over the Hubble tension and the assessment of evolving dark energy Confirmed .
- 1967Year the first pulsars were observed at Cambridge
- 1974Year of the Nobel Prize in Physics to Ryle and Hewish
- About 10 kilometersApproximate diameter of a neutron star
Black Hole Theory: From Schwarzschild to Hawking Radiation
ConfirmedShortly after the publication of general relativity, Karl Schwarzschild gave Einstein an exact solution for the gravitational field of a spherical mass; this solution later led to the description of the non-rotating black hole Confirmed . The event horizon is a boundary beyond which not even light escapes. The horizon radius (the Schwarzschild radius) is about 3 kilometers (a diameter of about 6 kilometers) for a mass equal to the Sun and about 9 millimeters (a diameter of about 1.8 centimeters) for a mass equal to the Earth. In January 1965, Roger Penrose used the concept of the trapped surface to show that the formation of a black hole is a robust prediction of general relativity, and in 2020 he received half of the Nobel Prize in Physics for this work Confirmed .
In 1970, Penrose and Stephen Hawking generalized the singularity theorems and showed that, under general conditions, gravitational collapse and even the expansion of the Universe lead to a singularity. Hawking also put forward the area theorem: the area of an event horizon does not decrease in classical processes, and in the merger of two black holes the final area is at least equal to the sum of the two initial areas Confirmed . In February 1974 he announced a startling result: if quantum field theory is applied on a black hole background, the black hole should radiate like a body with a definite temperature; this is a theoretical prediction (a semiclassical calculation) and has not yet been observed Hypothesis .
The Hawking temperature for a stellar-mass black hole is about ten to the power of minus seven kelvin per solar mass, which is far below the temperature of the cosmic microwave background. Therefore, Hawking radiation from real black holes has not been observed to date Confirmed . Laboratory analogue experiments, such as optical and acoustic systems, investigate a similar phenomenon, but these are not direct tests of the cosmic black hole. The "information paradox," that is, the question of what happens to the information of the matter that fell into a black hole when it evaporates, remains a fundamental unsolved problem at the junction of general relativity and quantum mechanics Open question .
An important point for the reader is that the mathematical model of the black hole and the existence of compact masses in nature are two different levels. The existence of such objects has been definitively confirmed through orbital observations, gravitational waves and imaging Confirmed , but their internal structure, that is, the actual existence of a singularity, is predicted in classical theory and is more a sign of the limit of the theory's validity than an observed reality Open question .
- 1965Penrose's proof that black hole formation is a robust prediction
- February 1974Announcement of Hawking radiation (theoretical calculation, not observed)
- 3 kilometersEvent horizon radius of a black hole with the mass of the Sun (diameter about 6 kilometers)
Observing Black Holes: Cygnus X-1, LIGO and EHT Images
ConfirmedCygnus X-1 was among the first X-ray sources to be identified as a stellar black hole candidate. A more precise radio measurement of its distance in 2021 estimated it at about 2.22 kiloparsecs (with an uncertainty of 0.18) and raised the black hole's mass to about 21.2 solar masses with an uncertainty of 2.2; the mass of the companion star was found to be close to 40.6 solar masses, far more than earlier estimates Confirmed .
On September 14, 2015, the LIGO detectors recorded the first gravitational wave from the merger of two black holes (GW150914); the wave had been traveling for about 1.3 billion years. The 2017 Nobel Prize went to Rainer Weiss (one half) and Barry Barish and Kip Thorne (the other half) Confirmed . Hundreds of events have now been recorded. In 2025, the event GW250114, with two black holes of about 34 and 32 solar masses, had the highest signal-to-noise ratio observed up to that time; its analysis confirmed Hawking's area theorem and measured two quasinormal modes of the final black hole (announced on September 10, 2025) Confirmed . The event GW231123, observed on November 23, 2023 and announced on July 14, 2025, involved components of about 100 and 140 solar masses and a total mass between 190 and 265 solar masses, and was identified as the largest merger recorded up to that time Confirmed . How such heavy black holes arose from stellar evolution Open question is still debated.
On April 10, 2019, the Event Horizon Telescope collaboration, using eight radio telescopes, released the first image of a black hole's shadow at the center of the galaxy Messier 87: a bright ring with a dark center, at a distance of about 55 million light-years and with a mass of about 6.5 billion Suns Confirmed . On May 12, 2022, a similar image of Sagittarius A*, with a mass of about four million Suns, was presented, based on 2017 data Confirmed . These images are consistent with the prediction of general relativity for the size of the shadow, although the precision of the test is still limited.
- 21.2 ± 2.2Mass of the Cygnus X-1 black hole (solar masses), 2021 estimate
- September 14, 2015First direct observation of a gravitational wave
- April 10, 2019Release of the first image of a black hole shadow (M87*)
The Milky Way and the Gaia Map
ConfirmedThe Milky Way is a spiral galaxy whose stellar disk extends more than 100 thousand light-years. NASA estimates the number of its stars at probably 100 to 400 billion; this wide range shows that an exact count is not possible, because from inside the galaxy one cannot completely see the low-mass, faint stars or the parts hidden behind dust Confirmed . The Solar System lies roughly halfway between the center and the edge, and each complete revolution around the galaxy takes about 220 to 250 million years (the commonly cited figure is about 230 million years).
ESA's Gaia satellite has measured the positions and motions of nearly two billion stars, a small fraction of the galaxy's stars, which are used to build a three-dimensional map of the galaxy and its motions Confirmed . According to ESA, Gaia data show that the spiral arms are more numerous than two and less prominent than previously thought, and that the central bar is at a larger angle relative to the Sun; further data releases are planned from the first decade of the mission Confirmed .
At the center of the galaxy, a very massive, invisible object makes the stars orbit around it. Two groups led by Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez, beginning in the early 1990s, tracked the motion of the brightest stars near the center, Sagittarius A*, and found about four million solar masses in a region smaller than the Solar System. The star S2 completes one full orbit in about 16 years, and this made it possible to trace its entire orbit; for this reason, half of the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics went to Genzel and Ghez Confirmed . How supermassive black holes grew so quickly in the early Universe Open question is a subject of active research.
Estimates of distance and mass use different methods in different parts of the galaxy. Because we are inside the galaxy, as ESA writes, we cannot take a complete picture of it from outside and must build the map star by star Confirmed . For this reason, all figures concerning size, number of stars and the structure of the arms are revised as data improve, and should be read as ranges.
- About 100 thousand light-yearsExtent of the Milky Way's stellar disk
- 100 to 400 billionNASA's estimate of the number of stars
- About 2 billionStars mapped by Gaia
Galaxies, Clusters and the Cosmic Web
ConfirmedGalaxies are mainly of two shapes, spiral and elliptical, and a third group, the irregulars, have a disordered appearance Confirmed . Galaxies gather in groups of about a hundred members or fewer and in clusters of thousands of members; these aggregations are themselves organized into larger structures. This classification is based on appearance and reflects different stellar compositions and formation histories; ellipticals usually have older stars and less gas [hypothesis for the details of evolution; the general description is confirmed].
On very large scales, galaxies are gathered along filaments stretched between vast voids, and the whole network is called the cosmic web. Simulations based on cold dark matter predict such a structure, and observations are consistent with it Confirmed . One recent piece of evidence is an ESA observation in June 2025 of a filament about 23 million light-years long that connects four clusters in the Shapley Supercluster and contains hot gas at a temperature above ten million degrees; its mass was estimated at about ten times that of the Milky Way Confirmed .
This finding relates to the puzzle of the "missing matter": more than one third of the matter that should exist in the nearby Universe (ordinary, or baryonic, matter) had until then not been found in observations, and it is thought to be hidden in just such filaments of hot, tenuous gas. Researchers have said the result is highly consistent with the standard model of cosmology Confirmed , although the statistics of such detections are still limited and a full picture requires more samples Open question . The Euclid mission, launched on July 1, 2023, is designed to map this very structure and the distribution of dark matter Confirmed .
- About 23 million light-yearsLength of the hot gas filament found in the Shapley Supercluster (2025)
- More than one thirdShare of the nearby Universe's ordinary matter that had previously not been traced
- July 1, 2023Launch date of Euclid
Dark Matter: The Evidence and the Unknown Nature
Open questionThe first clue came in 1933 from Fritz Zwicky: he saw in the Coma Cluster that galaxies move so fast that the gravity of visible matter cannot hold them, and he called the invisible matter "dunkle Materie" Confirmed . In 1970, Vera Rubin and Kent Ford published the flat rotation curve of the Andromeda Galaxy, and in the following decade extended it to dozens of galaxies; stars at the edges orbit at nearly the same speed as stars near the center, which does not fit the visible mass Confirmed . According to ESA, the missing mass in a typical galaxy is about ten times the mass of its stars.
The strongest direct evidence is not rotation but this very structure of mass distribution. In the collision of the clusters of the "Bullet Cluster" (2006, at a distance of about 3.8 billion light-years), the mass map from gravitational lensing does not coincide with the position of the hot X-ray gas, which holds most of the ordinary matter; this indicates that most of the mass is a kind of collisionless matter Confirmed . The cosmic microwave background and the formation of structures also favor cold dark matter. Planck estimated its share at about 26.8 percent Confirmed .
Nevertheless, the particle that makes up dark matter has still not been identified. The main candidates are WIMPs, which are heavy, slow-moving particles, axions, which are light particles, and primordial black holes, and none of them has been confirmed Hypothesis . Direct-search experiments, indirect detection and accelerators have not yet given a definitive result. We therefore regard "dark matter exists" as a confirmed gravitational effect, but "what dark matter is" is an open question Open question .
- 1933Zwicky and the Coma Cluster
- 1970Publication of the Andromeda rotation curve by Rubin and Ford
- 26.8%Share of dark matter according to Planck
Alternatives: Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND)
HypothesisIn 1983, Mordehai Milgrom proposed that, instead of adding dark matter, the law of gravity should be modified at very small accelerations; its reference acceleration is about 1.2 times ten to the power of minus ten meters per second squared. MOND explains the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation naturally, that is, the fixed relation between a galaxy's stellar-plus-gas mass and its rotation speed, and the measured exponent of close to 3.94 agrees with the predicted value of 4. The analytical review that is our source records these successes for many spiral and low-surface-brightness galaxies [confirmed as a description of the data; hypothesis as a theory].
But MOND runs into trouble on larger scales: the same review admits that in galaxy clusters the predicted acceleration is too low by roughly a factor of two, and that it does not fit the third acoustic peak of the cosmic microwave background precisely. Moreover, its theoretical Lagrangian foundation is unclear, and relativistic versions, including BIMOND and the QUMOND formulation, have not yet been completed. The author of that review is himself a supporter of MOND, so the assessment should be read with caution. The Bullet Cluster and cosmic structure are also serious challenges for models without dark matter Hypothesis .
The situation today is that the cosmology community mainly regards cold dark matter as the more effective model on all scales, but MOND itself and its hybrid versions are still being studied at the galactic scale. Neither approach is a complete and final explanation; the existence of a theory that simultaneously reproduces the behavior of galaxies, clusters and the microwave background without dark matter has not been proven Open question .
- 1983Proposal of MOND by Milgrom
- About 1.2e-10 m/s²Reference acceleration a0
- A factor of about 2Predicted acceleration shortfall in clusters, according to the source review
Dark Energy: The 1998 Discovery and the DESI Hints
Open questionIn the late 1990s, observations of distant Type Ia supernovae showed that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating, something that known physics did not predict Confirmed . The 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics went half to Saul Perlmutter and one quarter each to Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess. "Dark energy" is the general name for the unknown cause of this acceleration, and in the standard model it is described by the cosmological constant; according to Planck, its share is about 68.3 percent Confirmed .
On March 19, 2025, the DESI collaboration released its third-year results (DR2) with approximately 15 million galaxies and quasars, and the precision of baryon acoustic oscillations became roughly twice that of the first-year data. Combining these data with the microwave background, supernovae and, in some analyses, weak lensing indicates a preference for dark energy that changes with time, with a strength of 2.8 to 4.2 sigma depending on the data combination; none reaches the 5-sigma threshold of discovery [confirmed as a statistical result; its interpretation is a hypothesis].
An analysis in June 2026 based on the full six-year DES dataset found a similar tendency, with a preference of 2.2 sigma for the single project, 2.3 when adding BAO from DESI DR2, and about 3.0 sigma when adding the microwave background Confirmed . The upshot is that evidence from several experiments points in one direction but remains moderate. A systematic error, especially in the calibration of supernovae, or new physics may be the cause. The final decision will come from Euclid, Rubin and Roman data and the next DESI release Open question .
It is important for the reader to understand what "sigma" means: 3 sigma means that, if the cosmological-constant model is correct, such a deviation would occur with a probability of about one in several hundred, but particle physics demands 5 sigma for a claim of discovery. The phrase "growing evidence" is therefore more accurate than "discovery," and DESI's own sources are cautious as well: one member of the team said these measurements show evidence that the standard model is not the best explanation, not that they have ruled it out Confirmed .
- 2011Nobel Prize in Physics for the discovery of accelerating expansion (Perlmutter, Schmidt, Riess)
- 2.8 to 4.2 sigmaDESI DR2 evidence for evolving dark energy
- About 15 millionGalaxies and quasars analyzed in DR2
The Hubble Tension: Two Values for One Number
Open questionThe Hubble constant is the present-day rate of cosmic expansion and is measured in km/s/Mpc. The standard model, using the cosmic microwave background, predicts a value of about 67.3 to 67.4 [confirmed as a result of the Planck analysis]. After adding ACT data and BAO from DESI, the same model gives 68.2 to 68.4 with a precision of about 0.3 Confirmed . By contrast, local measurements based on the distance ladder are higher: SH0ES has reported about 73.0 (±1.0).
In October 2025, the consensus report of the "Local Distance Network" (H0DN) gave a value of 73.50 ± 0.81 with a precision of about one percent, which differs by about 7.1 sigma from the flat ΛCDM model based on Planck+SPT+ACT and by about 5.0 sigma when BBN and BAO from DESI are combined [confirmed as published results]. The CCHP group, using JWST and Hubble, arrived at 70.39 and considers the discrepancy to be much smaller, but critics such as Dan Scolnic say that they excluded some of the supernovae; the surface brightness fluctuation method with JWST gave 73.8, and the TDCOSMO collaboration using gravitational lensing gave 72.1 [confirmed as reports; interpretations are disputed].
A June 2026 review concludes that the gap does not depend on a single dataset or method, and that simple solutions, whether in the early Universe or in the distance ladder, are under serious constraint Open question . Two possible explanations have been put forward: unknown systematic errors in the distance ladder, or new physics. Neither has yet been proven. It must therefore be said that the Hubble tension is real and persistent in the data, but its cause, and even its exact size, is an open question Open question .
To understand the discrepancy, we need to know the methods. The "distance ladder" begins at nearby distances with Cepheid variable stars and tip of the red giant branch stars, and continues with Type Ia supernovae out to the more distant Universe. The early-Universe method, by contrast, starts from the size of the sound horizon in the microwave background and infers today's value with the ΛCDM model. A 2026 study using 88 independent measurements of the sound horizon showed that the discrepancy may be better seen as lying between the distance ladder and all other methods, not merely between the early and late Universe Hypothesis .
- 73.50 ± 0.81Local Hubble constant based on the H0DN network (km/s/Mpc)
- About 67.3Value derived from the microwave background (Planck)
- 70.39Result of the CCHP group with JWST (km/s/Mpc)
Cosmic Inflation
HypothesisCosmic inflation is a hypothesis about a very rapid, accelerating expansion in a tiny fraction of the first second, which explains the flatness and horizon problems and whose quantum fluctuations supplied the seeds of the anisotropies of the microwave background and of large-scale structure Hypothesis . A recent review lists the roles of Starobinsky (1980), Guth (1981), Linde and Albrecht-Steinhardt (1982) as founders.
The observational evidence is consistent but not conclusive: the Universe is flat to within the precision of observation, and Planck gave the spectral index as 0.9649 ± 0.0042, which is nearly scale-invariant; combining ACT and Planck reached 0.9709 ± 0.0038, and some analyses go even higher, which some researchers attribute to parameter correlations or data discrepancies [confirmed as numbers; their interpretation is an open question]. Primordial gravitational waves have not yet been seen, and the tensor-to-scalar ratio is below about 0.036 to 0.038.
In this way, simple models with a large r have been set aside, but models such as Starobinsky's are still alive. We still do not know what field drove inflation, and inflation as a theory has no final proof; its decisive test, the detection of primordial gravitational waves in the B-mode polarization of the microwave background, awaits more sensitive experiments Open question .
It should be stressed that the absence of primordial gravitational waves does not mean the refutation of inflation; many models predict a very small tensor-to-scalar ratio, and only the simpler models with a large r are under pressure Hypothesis . Inflation theory is simultaneously being questioned and completed, and several alternative models for the early Universe, including different reheating paths and early dark energy, are being examined Open question .
- 0.9649 ± 0.0042Spectral index n_s based on Planck
- Less than about 0.04Upper limit on the tensor-to-scalar ratio r
- 1980 to 1982Period in which inflation models were proposed
Tests of General Relativity
ConfirmedGeneral relativity has so far been tested from the scale of the Solar System to the merger of black holes Confirmed . NASA's Gravity Probe B satellite measured two effects: the geodetic drift of gyroscopes, which was measured with a precision of about 0.28 percent, a value of 6601.8 ± 18.3 milliarcseconds per year against a prediction of 6606.1; and frame dragging, 37.2 ± 7.2 against a prediction of 39.2, which was confirmed with a precision of about 19 percent. Both are consistent with the theory to within about one sigma Confirmed .
In the strong-field regime, gravitational waves are a new test. GW250114 allowed researchers to test Hawking's area theorem and the Kerr nature of the black hole with unprecedented precision and to measure two quasinormal modes of the final black hole; agreement with the prediction of general relativity has been reported Confirmed . The shadow of black holes in EHT images is also consistent with the theory's prediction, but the precision is still not sufficient to distinguish alternatives.
Nevertheless, general relativity is not complete. It has not been reconciled with quantum mechanics, it breaks down at singularities, and on the cosmic scale it requires dark matter and dark energy. General relativity has so far not failed any valid test, but consistency with all observations does not mean the end of the search; a quantum theory of gravity does not yet exist Open question .
Each test has its own particular domain: Gravity Probe B measures the weak field of the Earth, gravitational waves measure the strong, dynamic field, and the EHT measures the proximity of the horizon. None of them alone tests the entire theory, but together they give a unified picture of the theory's consistency Confirmed .
- 6601.8 ± 18.3Measured geodetic drift (mas/yr), prediction 6606.1
- 37.2 ± 7.2Measured frame dragging (mas/yr), prediction 39.2
- September 10, 2025Announcement of the area theorem test with GW250114
The Multiverse and What We Do Not Know
Open questionAccording to Planck's estimate, ordinary matter is only about 4.9 percent, dark matter about 26.8 percent and dark energy about 68.3 percent of the content of the Universe; ESA and NASA also emphasize these same proportions and say that about 95 percent of the Universe is made of dark matter and dark energy [confirmed as an estimate within the framework of the standard model]. These figures come from fitting the model to converge with observations, and if the model changes, they will change; so "95 percent" is a picture of our ignorance, not a list of known components Open question .
The "multiverse" is the assumption that our Universe is one of very many possible universes; in some formulations it follows from eternal inflation or string theory. This idea is entirely at the level of theoretical conjecture Hypothesis : so far no observation or experiment has shown its existence, and it is still unclear how it could be tested in a principled way. Many physicists do not regard it as scientific unless it offers a testable prediction, and some consider it promising.
There are other major open questions as well: the nature of the dark matter particle, whether dark energy changes or is constant, the cause of the Hubble tension, the physics of singularities and the evolution of black holes, and the mechanism of inflation. In the coming years, Euclid, whose DR1-Foundation data release is planned for November 12, 2026 and whose full DR1 is planned for mid-2027 (the dates are not firm), together with DESI, Rubin, Roman and the continuing operation of LIGO, will clarify some of these questions Open question .
- 4.9% / 26.8% / 68.3%Ordinary matter / dark matter / dark energy (Planck)
- 95Unknown share
- November 12, 2026Planned date of the DR1-Foundation release of the Euclid mission (not firm)
Timeline
20 events- 1915 to 1916Publication of general relativity and the Schwarzschild solution for the field of a spherical mass, the foundation of black hole theoryConfirmed
- 1933Fritz Zwicky, studying the Coma Cluster, proposes the existence of invisible matterConfirmed
- 1965Roger Penrose proves that black hole formation is a robust prediction of general relativityConfirmed
- 1967Discovery of the first pulsars at Cambridge, led by Antony HewishConfirmed
- 1970Vera Rubin and Kent Ford publish the flat rotation curve of Andromeda; Hawking and Penrose extend the singularity theoremsConfirmed
- February 1974Stephen Hawking announces black hole radiation; it has not yet been observedHypothesis
- 1974Nobel Prize in Physics to Martin Ryle and Antony HewishConfirmed
- 1980 to 1982Proposal of cosmic inflation models (Starobinsky, Guth, Linde, Albrecht and Steinhardt)Hypothesis
- 1983Milgrom proposes MONDHypothesis
- Late 1990sObservations of distant supernovae show that the expansion of the Universe is acceleratingConfirmed
- 2006Analysis of the Bullet Cluster provides more direct evidence for dark matterConfirmed
- 2011Nobel Prize in Physics to Perlmutter, Schmidt and Riess for the discovery of accelerating expansionConfirmed
- September 14, 2015LIGO records the first gravitational wave from the merger of two black holesConfirmed
- April 10, 2019The EHT collaboration releases the first image of a black hole shadow (M87*)Confirmed
- 2021The mass of the Cygnus X-1 black hole is revised to about 21 solar massesConfirmed
- May 12, 2022Release of the first image of Sagittarius A*Confirmed
- March 19, 2025DESI releases DR2 results with a preference of 2.8 to 4.2 sigma for evolving dark energyOpen question
- July to September 2025Announcement of GW231123 (July 14) and of GW250114 with the area theorem test (September 10)Confirmed
- October 2025Publication of the H0DN report with a local Hubble constant of 73.50 ± 0.81Open question
- June 2026Full six-year DES results; a preference of 2 to 3 sigma for evolving dark energyOpen question
Common misconceptions
A black hole swallows everything like a vacuum cleaner.
Only what comes close enough is trapped. If we replaced the Sun with a black hole of the same mass, gravity far from it would not change and the planets' orbits would remain the same. The event horizon for a mass equal to the Sun has a radius of only about 3 kilometers (a diameter of about 6 kilometers).
The EHT image is an ordinary photograph of the black hole itself.
The image shows the black hole's shadow against the glowing gas around it and was reconstructed from the radio data of several telescopes; it is not a direct optical photograph. In fact, it is a mathematical reconstruction that is consistent with the prediction of general relativity.
It has been proven that dark energy is weakening.
The DESI and DES results give hints at the level of 2 to 4 sigma, and none has reached the 5-sigma threshold of discovery. A systematic error may be the cause; so this is still an open question, not a definitive conclusion.
The Hubble tension has been resolved or is merely a measurement error.
Some groups, such as CCHP, report a value closer to the microwave background, but the H0DN network and independent methods such as gravitational lensing and surface brightness fluctuations still give higher values. The 2026 review regards it as real and without a simple solution.
MOND has refuted dark matter.
MOND fits some galactic behaviors well, but it has trouble with clusters and the microwave background. Standard cosmology regards cold dark matter as more successful on all scales, although the dark matter particle has still not been found.
The multiverse is a proven scientific theory.
The multiverse is at the level of theoretical conjecture, arising from some formulations of inflation or string theory, and so far it has no testable observation.
Open questions
No definitive answer yet- What particle or phenomenon is dark matter made of, and why has direct detection so far yielded no result?
- Is dark energy constant or does it change with time, and will the DESI and DES hints reach 5 sigma or turn out to be systematic errors?
- Why does the Hubble constant take different values from the distance ladder and from the microwave background? Systematic error or new physics?
- What mechanism drove cosmic inflation, and will primordial gravitational waves be detected?
- What happens to information when a black hole evaporates, and will Hawking radiation ever be observed?
- How did supermassive black holes grow so quickly in the early Universe?
- How can general relativity be reconciled with quantum mechanics?
Frequently asked questions
A mass of about 1.4 times the mass of the Sun, above which a white dwarf cannot keep itself stable. Approaching it in binary systems can trigger a Type Ia supernova.
In 1967, Antony Hewish's group at Cambridge found radio sources with regular pulses about one second apart; these were later identified as rotating neutron stars. Hewish received the Nobel Prize in 1974.
Sagittarius A* has about four million solar masses. The motion of stars such as S2 and the EHT image in 2022 have confirmed this mass.
NASA estimates 100 to 400 billion. This is an estimate, not a count; Gaia has mapped about two billion stars.
No. Dark matter, like ordinary matter, attracts gravitationally and shapes structures, but dark energy is the cause of the acceleration of expansion. According to Planck, the proportions are about 26.8 and 68.3 percent.
It means that local measurements of the Hubble constant (about 73.5) do not agree with the value derived from the cosmic microwave background (about 67.3). The discrepancy has been reported to exceed 5 sigma, and its cause is still unknown.
It has been consistent in all direct tests, from Gravity Probe B to black hole mergers. But it is incompatible with quantum mechanics, and a more complete theory does not yet exist.
It is the idea of the existence of multiple universes, which for now is theoretical conjecture and has not been confirmed by any observation or experiment. Its scientific value depends on whether it offers a testable prediction.
Sources
30 references- The Nobel Prize in Physics 2011NobelPrize.org · nobelprize.org
- DESI DR2 results, March 19 guideDESI / Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory · desi.lbl.gov
- Evidence Mounts for Evolving Dark Energy, DESI Results FindUniversity of Texas at Dallas · news.utdallas.edu
- Constraints on Dynamical Dark Energy from Multiple Probes in the Full Dark Energy SurveyarXiv (DES Collaboration) · arxiv.org
- Cosmic conflict continues: new data fuel the Hubble tension debatePhysics World · physicsworld.com
- The Local Distance Network: a community consensus report on the measurement of the Hubble constant at 1% precisionarXiv (H0DN Collaboration) · arxiv.org
- The Hubble tension: A decade reviewarXiv · arxiv.org
- The Nobel Prize in Physics 2020, popular science backgroundNobelPrize.org · nobelprize.org
- GW250114: 10 years of gravitational-wave astronomyLIGO Scientific Collaboration · ligo.org
- GW231123LIGO Scientific Collaboration · ligo.org
- Gravity Probe B: Final Results of a Space Experiment to Test General RelativityStanford University / Physical Review Letters · einstein.stanford.edu
- Press release: The 2017 Nobel Prize in PhysicsNobelPrize.org · nobelprize.org
- Press release: The Nobel Prize in Physics 2020NobelPrize.org · nobelprize.org
- First image of our black hole (Sagittarius A*)ESO · astropix.org
- Press Release (April 10, 2019): Astronomers Capture First Image of a Black HoleEvent Horizon Telescope · eventhorizontelescope.org
- Cygnus X-1 contains a 21-solar mass black holearXiv (Miller-Jones et al.) · arxiv.org
- Milky WayESA Gaia · cosmos.esa.int
- The models were right: astronomers find missing matterESA · esa.int
- Our Milky Way Galaxy: How Big is Space?NASA Science · science.nasa.gov
- Planck's new cosmic recipeESA · sci.esa.int
- Press release: The 1974 Nobel Prize in PhysicsNobelPrize.org · nobelprize.org
- Stellar Evolution: Cycles of Formation and DestructionChandra X-ray Observatory · chandra.harvard.edu
- Stellar ExplosionsNASA Science (Hubble) · science.nasa.gov
- Stephen William Hawking: A Biographical MemoirarXiv · arxiv.org
- Dark MatterNASA Science · science.nasa.gov
- Who was Vera Rubin?Carnegie Science · carnegiescience.edu
- MOND: a reviewarXiv · arxiv.org
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 power spectra, likelihoods and LCDM parametersarXiv (ACT Collaboration) · arxiv.org
- Inflation in a nutshell: From basics to latest advancesarXiv · arxiv.org
- Euclid timelineESA Cosmos · cosmos.esa.int
The text of this chapter is a rewrite and summary of the findings of the sources above and does not replace reading them. Links open external websites.