Space Research/Chapter 5
History of astronomy

How Humans Have Looked at the Sky:From Stone Alignments to the Expanding Universe

Humans were gazing at the sky thousands of years before the telescope was invented, recording the motion of the Sun and Moon and building calendars and maps from it. This chapter follows the path from prehistoric monuments and Greek instruments, through the star catalogs and observatories of the Islamic era, the Copernican revolution and Galileo's telescope, to the measurement of the first stellar distance and the discovery of other galaxies. Every claim carries the label “confirmed”, “hypothesis” or “open question”, so that the boundary between evidence and interpretation stays clear.

23 min read14 sections30 sourcesUpdated: October 31, 2026
1,543CEPublication of Copernicus's De revolutionibus in Nuremberg
1,609CEGalileo's first telescopic observations and the publication of Kepler's Astronomia Nova
1,838CEBessel's publication of the first reliable stellar parallax, for 61 Cygni
1,923CEHubble's identification of the variable star V1 in Andromeda
13.8billion yearsAge of the universe according to the final data of the Planck satellite
01

The Sky Before Writing: Monuments and the Nebra Disc

Hypothesis

Confirmed The oldest evidence of organized sky-watching comes from structures and objects built before writing. At Stonehenge, the large sarsen stones were raised around 2500 BCE, and the main axis of the monument frames the sunrise at the summer solstice and the sunset at the winter solstice. Field surveys have shown that the stones along this axis were dressed more carefully, and the entrance way of the monument is aligned with the same axis. The monument was built and rearranged in several phases over the period from about 3000 to 1520 BCE.

Hypothesis The purpose for which these alignments were built is a matter of interpretation. The British Museum notes that the monument was probably more than a calendar and had ritual meaning; the cremated remains of about 150 people from an earlier phase suggest that the solstices may have been an occasion for commemorating ancestors. The alignment with the Sun is therefore documented, but the word “observatory” as applied to Stonehenge is a modern interpretation and cannot be taken to mean systematic research in the present-day sense.

Hypothesis The Nebra sky disc is another example. It was found in 1999 with a metal detector on a hill in Germany, and because it lacked a reliable archaeological context, its date of about 1600 BCE has been set on the basis of the style of the swords and axes found with it. It shows a crescent Moon, a disc, about 23 stars, and a cluster of stars that many identify as the Pleiades; the two golden arcs at its sides are about 82 degrees apart, which has been considered consistent with the range of the Sun's movement between the solstices at that latitude. In 2004 a claim was made that it was a forgery, but later tests, including tracing the copper to a mine in the Austrian Alps, confirmed its authenticity. The meaning of each motif, including the third arc, is still debated.

Open question The boundary between “observation” and “symbolism” is not clear in these finds. The alignment of a structure with a sunrise point shows that its builders knew that point, but there is no written record on whether they recorded and predicted the motions or merely held ceremonies at that time, and the arguments are inevitably indirect.

  • ≈2500 BCERaising of the sarsen stones at Stonehenge
  • 1999Year the Nebra sky disc was discovered
  • ≈82°Angular separation of the two side arcs of the Nebra disc
02

From the Antikythera Mechanism to Measuring the Earth in the Greek World

Open question

Confirmed In 1901, divers working on a shipwreck near Crete found bronze fragments that are now known as the Antikythera Mechanism. According to museum reports, about 82 corroded fragments survive, with 37 gears, and the device tracked the motion of the Sun and Moon and predicted lunar and solar eclipses. It is an exceptional example of mechanical astronomical calculation in the ancient world.

Open question The date of its construction is disputed: earlier methods suggested a range of about 100 to 150 BCE, but a recent study, finding the eclipse of 205 BCE on one of the dials, pushes the date back by about 50 to 100 years and regards its mathematics as closer to Babylonian calculations than to Greek trigonometry. This example shows that Babylonian observational knowledge was in circulation before the Greek period, but the exact route of its transmission and the place where the device was made (Rhodes is the most likely candidate) are still not settled. The sources consulted for this chapter did not give sufficient coverage of the historiography of Babylonian tablets and ancient Egypt; for that reason, no detailed claims about them are included here.

Confirmed Eratosthenes (about 274 to 194 BCE) is reported to have used a geometric method in Alexandria to measure the size of the Earth, which Cleomedes relates: at noon on the summer solstice, a vertical rod at Syene (Aswan) casts no shadow but in Alexandria it does, and from the ratio of the shadow to the height the angle of difference in latitude can be found. The reported result is about 250 thousand stadia. There was also a naive assumption involved: the two cities do not lie on exactly the same meridian.

Open question Because the length of the stadion is unknown, its true accuracy cannot be judged with certainty; depending on the assumed length, the result comes out between about 39 thousand and 46 thousand kilometers. The statement “Eratosthenes measured the Earth with astonishing accuracy” is therefore more definite than the evidence allows.

  • 1901Discovery of the Antikythera Mechanism fragments
  • ≈250,000 stadiaCircumference of the Earth as reported by Cleomedes from Eratosthenes
  • ≈39,000 to 46,000 kmRange of the result depending on the assumed length of the stadion
03

Ptolemy, the Almagest and the Star Catalog

Hypothesis

Confirmed In the Almagest, written around the middle of the second century CE, Ptolemy gives a catalog of about 1,028 stars in 48 constellations, with three stars repeated in two constellations. Positions are given as ecliptic longitude and latitude, and this framework remained the basis of later catalogs for centuries, including the catalog of Ulugh Beg, which follows its order of constellations and stars.

Hypothesis One of the serious debates in the history of astronomy is how much of this catalog is Ptolemy's own observation. Analysis of the errors shows that its coordinates are very close to Hipparchus's data: if two catalogs were independent, their errors should not be correlated, yet here the correlation is high. According to this analysis, which appears in Dennis Duke's lecture notes, Ptolemy converted Hipparchus's coordinates to ecliptic longitude and carried them forward to his own time with a correction for the precession of the equinoxes (at a rate of 1 degree per 100 years). This interpretation is the common one but not without opponents, and other scholars have debated it.

Confirmed The more accurate rate of precession of the equinoxes is about 1 degree per 72 years, and the rate of 1 degree per century that Ptolemy used is smaller than it. This difference is also one of the reasons that correcting old coordinates to a later time introduces a systematic error. Even so, the Almagest presented a complete geometric scheme of planetary motion that remained the dominant framework until the time of Copernicus.

Confirmed The importance of the Almagest lay above all in the fact that it gathered geometry, numerical tables and methods of calculation into a single text. Later astronomers, from the Islamic world to Latin Europe, translated, commented on and criticized it; many of the innovations of Maragha, Samarkand and even Copernicus were in fact reactions to this framework, not a wholesale rejection of it.

  • 1,028Stars in Ptolemy's catalog (with three repeated)
  • 48Constellations in the catalog
  • ≈1° per 72 yrMore accurate rate of precession of the equinoxes
04

Al-Sufi and Biruni: Re-observation and Measuring the Earth

Confirmed

Confirmed Abd al-Rahman al-Sufi (903 to 986 CE) dedicated his Book of Fixed Stars (Suwar al-Kawakib al-Thabita) to Adud al-Dawla in 964 CE. He examined Ptolemy's catalog and illustrations on the basis of observation and review, and recorded the magnitudes of the stars anew. In that book, in the description of the constellation Andromeda, he mentions a “small cloud” near the mouth of the “Great Fish”, which is matched with the Andromeda Galaxy and, in review sources, is regarded as the earliest written reference to a galaxy outside the Milky Way.

Hypothesis The common claim that al-Sufi saw the Large Magellanic Cloud is weaker. Research by Hafez, Stephenson and Orchiston indicates that this identification is probably a misreading of a passage about the stars south of Canopus, which al-Sufi himself admits he had not seen. As for Andromeda, then, it can be said that he described it, but this did not mean he understood its galactic nature; that understanding became possible only after 1923.

Confirmed Abu Rayhan al-Biruni used a method for measuring the radius of the Earth that was carried out at the fort of Nandana in the Punjab: the height of a hill was determined from the angles at two points, and then the dip angle of the horizon was measured from the top of the hill. According to secondary reconstructions, the radius obtained is about 6,323 kilometers, which is close to the present-day value (about 6,357 to 6,378 kilometers); the exact percentage of error is not reliable because of uncertainty about the unit and the absence of raw data.

Open question This number depends on the conversion of the “Arabic mile”, and secondary sources do not provide the raw data (the height of the hill, the baseline and the angles); so the accuracy of Biruni's work can be regarded as credible and admirable, but its exact percentage depends on a unit that is doubtful.

Confirmed These two examples show that the astronomers of this period were not merely translators: al-Sufi tested Ptolemy's data against observation, and Biruni applied geometric methods to a quantity that could in practice be measured. The same attitude, that of re-examining inherited data, is seen later in Tycho and Kepler as well, although no direct document proves this link.

  • 964Dedication of the Book of Fixed Stars
  • ≈6,323 kmEarth's radius according to the reconstruction of Biruni's method
  • ≈6,357–6,378 kmPresent-day radius of the Earth, for comparison (accuracy of the reconstruction depends on the unit of the mile)
05

Khayyam and the Jalali Calendar

Hypothesis

Confirmed Omar Khayyam (born 18 May 1048 in Nishapur) was summoned to Isfahan after Malik-Shah came to the throne in 1072 and Isfahan became the Seljuk capital, to take part in building an observatory and drawing up a new calendar. The Jalali (Maliki) solar calendar was established around 1079 CE and aligned the beginning of the year with Nowruz, that is, the spring equinox. According to the sources, the year of this calendar was the mean interval between two spring equinoxes, and cycles of 4 and 5 years were used for leap years.

Hypothesis Khayyam's exact personal role in the calendar and the details of the observatory are poorly documented. Biographers stress that his position at court and the mention of his name in the works of later astronomers such as Tusi and Shirazi support the existence of a leading role, but the exact location of the observatory and whether the Zij-i Malikshahi emerged from that observatory or not are unconfirmed. MacTutor gives the length of his leadership as 18 years and adds that after the death of Malik-Shah and Nizam al-Mulk in 1092, funding was cut and the calendar reform came to a halt.

Open question The length of the year attributed to Khayyam, about 365.24219858 days, is very close to the modern value, but the exact leap-year pattern of the original is disputed among scholars, and the long-term accuracy of the calendar, in the words of the encyclopedia of astronomers, is an open question. Common claims of “one day of error in several thousand years” were not confirmed in the sources for this chapter and should be cited with caution.

  • 1079Year by which the Jalali calendar was at least in force
  • ≈18 yrStated duration of the observatory's work in Isfahan, according to MacTutor
  • 1092Death of Malik-Shah and end of support
06

Nasir al-Din al-Tusi and the Maragha Observatory

Confirmed

Confirmed Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (1201 to 1274) persuaded Hulagu Khan in 1259 to found an observatory at Maragha; according to encyclopedias, its construction and equipping took about three years. Its instruments included a huge copper mural quadrant, an azimuth quadrant and other instruments, and it also had a library. Chinese astronomers also worked there alongside Iranians. The result of the work was the Zij-i Ilkhani, which was written in Persian and contains 12 years of planetary observations.

Confirmed The “Tusi couple” is a mathematical device that converts uniform circular motion into oscillating linear motion, and astronomers of the Maragha school, including Ibn al-Shatir, used it to approximate the Ptolemaic equant without violating the uniformity of circular motion. This innovation links the modeling between Ptolemy and Copernicus.

Open question While the achievement of Maragha is documented, the claim that the observatory was the “first regular research center” or became a lasting model for the West is an exaggeration. The exact number of astronomers, their composition, and what remains of the observatory were not made clear in the sources for this chapter. A careful assessment of Maragha's role must be weighed in the shadow of the question of transmission to Europe (next section).

Confirmed Tusi was born in 1201 and died on 26 June 1274 near Baghdad. Hulagu, who took the Ismaili stronghold in 1256, took him under his patronage, and the title Ilkhan became the basis of the name Zij-i Ilkhani. This political context should not be ignored: the observatory was built with the support of a conquering ruler, and its survival depended on the stability of that same power.

  • 1259Founding of the Maragha Observatory at Tusi's proposal
  • ≈3 yrDuration of construction and preparation
  • 12 yrDuration of the planetary observations recorded in the Zij-i Ilkhani
07

Ulugh Beg and the Samarkand Observatory

Hypothesis

Confirmed Ulugh Beg (born about 1394, died 1449) founded a madrasa in Samarkand that was completed in 1420 and built an observatory whose construction probably began around 1428. His prominent colleagues were Ghiyath al-Din Jamshid al-Kashi and Qadi Zada. His Zij-i Sultani has 1,018 stars in 48 constellations, and its order is the same as the Almagest.

Confirmed Most of the longitudes and latitudes of the catalog were obtained from several years of observation at Samarkand, but 27 southern stars that are not visible from Samarkand were taken from another catalog and corrected for the precession of the equinoxes by 6 degrees and 59 minutes. This shows that part of the catalog is observational and part is adapted from an earlier source. Accuracy checks, including comparison with Hipparchus's catalog, are mentioned in the sources, but their numerical findings did not appear in the source for this chapter.

Hypothesis The dimensions of the large instrument, the Fakhri sextant, with a radius of about 36 meters, are given in one source, and the height of the building is stated as more than 35 meters and its diameter as 50 meters; but these numbers differ among sources. The same source gives the number of stars as 1,018 in one place and 992 in another, which shows that the count depends on the edition and the method of counting. The relation of the catalog to al-Sufi has also been raised in an article by Kunitzsch, but its details did not appear in the source for this chapter.

Confirmed The accuracies reported for the Zij-i Sultani are impressive: the length of the sidereal year in it is about 365 days, 6 hours, 10 minutes and 8 seconds, which differs from the present-day value by only about 58 seconds, and the tropical year is about 365 days, 5 hours, 49 minutes and 15 seconds, with an error of about 25 seconds. The tilt of the Earth's axis is also given as about 23 degrees, 30 minutes and 17 seconds. These figures were taken from a single source and should be checked against more specialized research.

  • 1,018Number of stars in Ulugh Beg's catalog (one source also gives 992)
  • 27Southern stars borrowed from another catalog
  • 1449Year of Ulugh Beg's death
08

Copernicus and the Question of Transmission from Maragha

Open question

Confirmed The book De revolutionibus orbium coelestium was published in Nuremberg by Johannes Petreius shortly before 21 March 1543; it was a 202-page edition whose print run is estimated at 400 to 500 copies, of which 277 survive. The book was dedicated to Pope Paul III, and in it the Earth revolves around the Sun as one of the planets. An unsigned preface, attributed to Andreas Osiander and added without the author's consent, presented the model as a “mathematical hypothesis”.

Confirmed In Book III, chapter 4, Copernicus uses the very same Tusi couple, and a passage that was deleted before publication referred to others who had used that device. A Greek manuscript (Vat. Gr. 211, about 1300) contains the Tusi couple and the lunar model, and it may have reached the Vatican in the fifteenth century. Copernicus named five Islamic authors, the latest of whom lived around 1200.

Open question How did these similarities reach Copernicus? Neugebauer and Swerdlow regard the route through Italy as more probable, Hartner considers independent discovery possible but borrowing more probable, di Bono regards independent rediscovery as at least equally probable, and Ragep says the mechanism of transmission is still unknown. No direct documented link has been found. Therefore the claims that “Copernicus stole from Islamic sources” and that “Copernicus was independent” both say more than the evidence does.

  • 1543Publication of the first edition in Nuremberg
  • 277Surviving copies of the first edition (Gingerich's estimate)
  • 5Islamic authors named by Copernicus
09

Tycho Brahe and Kepler: Precise Observation and the Laws of Motion

Confirmed

Confirmed In 1572 Tycho Brahe observed the new star in Cassiopeia and found no parallax; so it was far from the Earth and the sphere of the stars was not unchangeable. The comet of 1577 likewise had no measurable parallax. With the support of Frederick II of Denmark, he built the Uraniborg observatory on the island of Hven and between 1576 and 1597 recorded the positions of the planets with an accuracy of about one arcminute, the best accuracy without a telescope. He nevertheless believed in a stationary Earth at the center.

Confirmed Johannes Kepler (1571 to 1630) met Tycho in 1600 and became court astronomer after Tycho's death in 1601. In Astronomia Nova (1609) the first two laws appeared: the orbits of the planets are ellipses with the Sun at one focus, and the line joining the Sun and a planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times. The third law, which relates the orbital period to the size of the orbit, was found on 15 May 1618 and was described in Harmonices Mundi (1619).

Confirmed The important methodological point is that Kepler accepted that orbits are not combinations of uniform circles; this was the assumption that had gone unquestioned from Greek times to Copernicus. Tycho's precise data and Kepler's mathematics were both necessary, and neither would have produced that result without the other.

Hypothesis Historians usually point out that Kepler's progress did not come from a sudden idea; he struggled with the orbit of Mars for years, and part of his calculations rested on published data that the sources call somewhat doubtful. The narrative of a “sudden idea” is therefore a simplification, and the real process was gradual and full of trial and error.

  • ≈1 arcminAccuracy of Tycho's observations without a telescope
  • 1609Publication of Astronomia Nova
  • 1618-05-15Discovery of Kepler's third law
10

The Telescope and Galileo

Confirmed

Confirmed The first written document about the telescope is Hans Lipperhey's patent application of 2 October 1608 to the States General of the Netherlands. Sources give the date of the presentation to Prince Maurice as 25 September, which is a minor discrepancy between sources. The patent was not granted because the device was easy to make; Jacob Metius also made a similar application within two weeks, and others, including Zacharias Janssen, were also put forward. Who the “true inventor” is remains an open question.

Confirmed News of the device spread through a newsletter, and in November 1608 Paolo Sarpi passed it on to Galileo. In spring 1609 Galileo built a spyglass with a magnification of 3 times, in August 1609 presented an 8-times instrument to the Venetian Senate, and by December 1609 reached about 20 times. In December 1609 he observed the Moon and recorded its rough surface, and on 7 January 1610 he saw the moons of Jupiter for the first time.

Confirmed The results were published in Sidereus Nuncius (1610): the mountains and craters of the Moon, far more stars than are visible to the naked eye, and four moons of Jupiter that he called the “Medicean Stars”. Observation of the phases of Venus after autumn 1610 showed that Venus revolves around the Sun. The precise point is that Galileo did not invent the telescope; his contribution was improving its construction and turning it toward the sky.

Hypothesis A recent study, using sky simulation, has examined 64 of Galileo's sketches of the moons of Jupiter and estimated the periods of their orbits. This kind of re-examination suggests that the accuracy of Galileo's observations with the instrument of that time was greater than expected, but the exact resolving power of his instrument and some of the figures in that study are still subject to further scrutiny.

  • 1608-10-02Lipperhey's patent application
  • 1610-01-07Galileo's first observation of the moons of Jupiter
  • ≈20×Magnification of Galileo's instrument by December 1609
11

Newton, Gravitation and the Discovery of Uranus

Confirmed

Confirmed The Principia was published in July 1687. Edmond Halley urged Newton to publish and paid the printing costs himself, because the Royal Society lacked funds. The book presented the laws of motion, universal gravitation and its application to the orbits of planets and comets, and refuted Descartes's vortex theory, which was inconsistent with Kepler's laws. Newton himself said that he had not found the cause of gravity but had sufficiently demonstrated its existence and laws.

Confirmed On 13 March 1781, from the garden of his house in Bath, William Herschel saw, with a 6.2-inch Newtonian reflector, an object that had no tail and had a distinct disc. He called it a “comet” in a paper read at the Royal Society on 26 April 1781. Maskelyne and then Lexell, Saron and Laplace showed that its orbit resembled that of a planet. Herschel proposed the name Georgium Sidus for the king, but Bode proposed the name Uranus in 1783, and it stuck.

Confirmed Uranus is about twice as far from the Sun as Saturn, so its discovery roughly doubled the known size of the Solar System; it was the first planet found with a telescope. Historians stress that the discovery was neither pure chance nor the result of a deliberate search for a new planet; he was carrying out a systematic survey of the sky, and Herschel himself did not at first regard it as a planet.

Confirmed The link between these two sections is important: Kepler's laws and Newton's gravitation showed that planetary motion follows a single general principle, and the discovery of Uranus was the first major test of this picture, because its orbit could be examined with the same laws. Newton also stressed that he did not know the cause of gravity, and this scientific honesty should be recalled along with his results.

  • 1687Publication of the Principia
  • 1781-03-13Herschel's observation of Uranus
  • ≈2×Increase in the size of the known Solar System after Uranus
12

Bessel and the First Stellar Distance

Confirmed

Confirmed If the Earth revolves around the Sun, nearby stars should trace a small elliptical path against the background over the course of a year. Using the Fraunhofer heliometer (added to the Königsberg Observatory in 1829), Bessel followed the star 61 Cygni for about 18 months in 1837 and 1838 and in 1838 reported a parallax of 0.314 arcseconds, that is, a distance of 3.18 parsecs, or about 10.4 light-years.

Confirmed In 1840 he and Schlüter corrected the value to 0.348 arcseconds (2.87 parsecs). The present-day value is 0.292 arcseconds, or 3.42 parsecs (about 11.2 light-years). The initial value, with an error of about 7 to 8 percent in distance, was therefore remarkable for nineteenth-century instruments. It was the first direct measurement of the distance of a star and an empirical confirmation of the Earth's annual motion.

Hypothesis Whether Bessel was the first to “measure” stellar parallax depends on the criterion of acceptance; other astronomers were pursuing the same goal at the same time. Bessel was the first to publish a reliable and lasting result. This wording is more precise than “the first to measure a star”. Bessel also published in 1818 a reanalysis of Bradley's observations (3,222 stars), which underlay the accuracy of his work.

  • 0.314″Bessel's reported parallax for 61 Cygni (1838)
  • ≈10.4 lyEstimated distance in 1838
  • ≈11.2 lyPresent-day distance (3.42 parsecs)
13

The Great Debate and Other Galaxies

Confirmed

Confirmed In 1920 Harlow Shapley and Heber Curtis debated the scale of the universe: Shapley regarded the Milky Way as large and the spiral nebulae as part of it; Curtis regarded the Milky Way as smaller and the nebulae as separate “island universes”. The final answer came not from this debate but from observation.

Confirmed On the night of 5 October 1923, Edwin Hubble took a 45-minute photograph of Andromeda with the 100-inch Hooker telescope on Mount Wilson. The object V1 varied more slowly than a nova; he found a period of 31.4 days and recognized the star as a Cepheid variable. With the period-luminosity relation, the distance was estimated at about one million light-years, more than three times the size of the Milky Way in Shapley's estimate. By the end of 1924 the estimate was 900 thousand light-years; present-day measurements give about 2 million light-years.

Confirmed The paper was read at the end of December 1924 at the joint meeting of the AAS and AAAS, in Hubble's absence. Shapley is said to have remarked, on reading Hubble's letter, that it had destroyed his universe. But Hypothesis the phrase “Curtis won” is a simplification: important points on both sides were correct; for example, Shapley was right that the Milky Way is large and Curtis that the nebulae lie outside it.

Confirmed What made V1 important was that Cepheids were a distance ruler: the period of their light variation depends on their intrinsic luminosity, so comparing intrinsic and apparent brightness gives the distance. Hubble later found more Cepheids in Andromeda and revised the estimate; subsequent revisions of the distance scale brought it to about double the initial estimate.

  • 1923-10-05Night of Hubble's photograph of Andromeda
  • 31.4 dLight-variation period of the star V1
  • ≈2 million lyPresent-day distance of Andromeda
14

The Expanding Universe and the Road to Modern Cosmology

Confirmed

Confirmed In 1927 Georges Lemaître, using general relativity, predicted a linear relation between redshift and distance and estimated the expansion rate from galaxy data; the data were very tentative compared with Hubble's 1929 plot. In 1929 Hubble presented a plot of an approximately linear relation that the data supported only marginally. In the 1931 English translation of Lemaître's paper, the provisional discussion of radial velocities was cut down to a single line, and Lemaître himself said in a letter that he did not consider it appropriate to print it again.

Confirmed In 2018 the International Astronomical Union, in a vote (78 percent in favor, 20 percent against, 2 percent abstaining), recommended that the law be called the “Hubble–Lemaître” law; this recommendation is not binding. George Gamow predicted the background radiation in 1948, and Alpher and Herman continued the prediction in 1950. Penzias and Wilson observed it in 1965 at Bell Labs, Dicke's group at Princeton published the cosmological interpretation, and the two received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1978.

Confirmed The European Space Agency's Planck satellite mapped the small fluctuations of this radiation from 2009 to 2013; the final 2018 data estimate the age of the universe at about 13.8 billion years. Open question The Hubble constant in the early universe is 67.4 (±0.5) km/s/Mpc, which is slightly lower than the values measured in the later universe; this “Hubble tension” is still unresolved and is the subject of active debate.

  • 1927 / 1929Lemaître's paper and Hubble's plot
  • 1965Observation of the cosmic background radiation at Bell Labs
  • 67.4 ± 0.5Hubble constant from Planck data

Timeline

20 events
  • about 2500 BCERaising of the sarsen stones at Stonehenge, with an axis aligned with the solstices.Confirmed
  • about 1600 BCEProposed date of the Nebra sky disc, based on the finds accompanying it.Hypothesis
  • about 274 to 194 BCELifetime of Eratosthenes and the reported measurement of the Earth's circumference.Hypothesis
  • second or third century BCEConstruction of the Antikythera Mechanism; the exact date is debated (205 BCE proposed versus 100 to 150 BCE).Open question
  • about the middle of the second century CEPtolemy's Almagest with a catalog of 1,028 stars.Confirmed
  • 964 CEDedication of al-Sufi's Book of Fixed Stars to Adud al-Dawla.Confirmed
  • 1079 CEEstablishment of the Jalali calendar in the time of Malik-Shah.Confirmed
  • 1259 CEFounding of the Maragha Observatory at the proposal of Nasir al-Din al-Tusi.Confirmed
  • about 1420 to 1449 CEActivity of Ulugh Beg's Samarkand Observatory; the Zij-i Sultani with 1,018 stars.Hypothesis
  • 1543 CEPublication of Copernicus's De revolutionibus in Nuremberg.Confirmed
  • 1572 CETycho Brahe observes a new star without parallax.Confirmed
  • 2 October 1608Lipperhey's patent application for the telescope in the Netherlands.Confirmed
  • 1609 CEPublication of Astronomia Nova and the start of Galileo's telescopic observations.Confirmed
  • 7 January 1610Galileo sees the moons of Jupiter for the first time.Confirmed
  • July 1687Publication of Newton's Principia.Confirmed
  • 13 March 1781Herschel observes Uranus.Confirmed
  • 1838 CEBessel publishes the parallax of 61 Cygni.Confirmed
  • 5 October 1923Hubble records the star V1 in Andromeda and later recognizes it as a Cepheid variable.Confirmed
  • 1927 and 1929Lemaître's paper and Hubble's plot of the velocity-distance relation.Confirmed
  • 1965 CEPenzias and Wilson observe the cosmic background radiation.Confirmed

Common misconceptions

Common belief

Galileo invented the telescope.

Fact

The first written document is Lipperhey's application of 2 October 1608. After hearing the news in 1609, Galileo built his own instrument, improved it greatly and turned it toward the sky.

Common belief

Eratosthenes measured the Earth with astonishing accuracy and without doubt.

Fact

The result depends on the length of the stadion, which is unknown; depending on it, it comes out between about 39 thousand and 46 thousand kilometers. The method was sound, but the final accuracy is uncertain.

Common belief

Copernicus took his theory entirely from the Maragha astronomers.

Fact

The similarities between the models are documented, but no direct link of transmission has been found, and scholars debate between independent discovery and transmission.

Common belief

Al-Sufi observed the Large Magellanic Cloud.

Fact

This identification is probably a misreading of a passage about the stars south of Canopus, which al-Sufi himself had not seen. His description of Andromeda as a “small cloud”, however, is documented.

Common belief

Hubble alone discovered the expansion of the universe.

Fact

In 1927 Lemaître derived the relation from general relativity, and in 1929 Hubble presented the observational data. In 2018 the International Astronomical Union recommended the name “Hubble–Lemaître”.

Common belief

Bessel discovered the nearby star and its distance is exactly 10 light-years.

Fact

Bessel reported 0.314 arcseconds (about 10.4 light-years), and the later, present-day value is about 11.2 light-years.

Common belief

Khayyam's Jalali calendar was more accurate than the Gregorian calendar, with an error of “one day in 5000 years”.

Fact

The long-term accuracy of the Jalali calendar, in the words of specialist sources, is an open question, and the original leap-year pattern is disputed.

Open questions

No definitive answer yet
  • What was Khayyam's exact role in the Isfahan observatory and in drawing up the Jalali calendar, and what was the original leap-year pattern?
  • In what year was the Antikythera Mechanism built, and how did Babylonian knowledge reach it?
  • Did information from the Maragha models reach Copernicus, and if so, by what route?
  • How much of Ptolemy's star catalog is his own observation, and how much is taken from Hipparchus?
  • How many meters was Eratosthenes's stadion, and how accurate was his result?
  • What exactly were the astronomical and ritual uses of the Nebra disc and Stonehenge?
  • How will the Hubble tension between early-universe and late-universe measurements be resolved?

Frequently asked questions

The first written document is the application of Hans Lipperhey of the Netherlands on 2 October 1608; Jacob Metius and others also made claims. The true inventor is not definitively known.

In 1838 Bessel published a parallax of 0.314 arcseconds for 61 Cygni, consistent with a distance of about 10.4 light-years.

In 1923 he found the Cepheid variable star V1, related its 31.4-day period to its intrinsic luminosity, and obtained a distance of about one million light-years.

In 1259, at Tusi's proposal and with the support of Hulagu Khan; its construction took about three years and its product was the Zij-i Ilkhani.

A solar calendar that was established around 1079 CE in the time of Malik-Shah, aligned with Nowruz, and in whose drawing up Khayyam took part.

Yes; with Tycho's observational data and his own mathematics, Kepler published the first two laws in 1609 and the third law in 1619.

Herschel saw it on 13 March 1781 from Bath with a 6.2-inch reflector and at first took it for a comet; its orbit was then recognized as planetary.

Lemaître derived the relation theoretically in 1927 and Hubble presented broader data in 1929; the International Astronomical Union in 2018, with 78 percent in favor, recommended the combined name.

Sources

30 references
  1. Nasir al-Din al-TusiEncyclopedia.com · encyclopedia.com
  2. Bessel, Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers entryMacTutor, University of St Andrews · mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk
  3. Friedrich Wilhelm BesselEncyclopaedia Britannica · britannica.com:443
  4. Hubble views the star that changed the universeNASA Science · science.nasa.gov
  5. Khayyam, Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers entryMcGill University, Rare and Special Instruments project · islamsci.mcgill.ca
  6. Omar Khayyam biographyMacTutor, University of St Andrews · mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk
  7. Ulugh Beg, entry in Biographical EncyclopediaMacTutor, University of St Andrews · mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk
  8. Ulugh Beg star catalogueUtrecht University (R. H. van Gent) · webspace.science.uu.nl
  9. Scientist of the Day: Hans LipperheyLinda Hall Library · lindahall.org
  10. The telescopeCabinet, University of Oxford · cabinet.ox.ac.uk
  11. The invention of the telescopeExperimental Astronomy (Springer) · link.springer.com
  12. Of a comet [Uranus] seen on 13 March, by William HerschelRoyal Society, Making Science · makingscience.royalsociety.org
  13. March 13 marks 240 years since Herschel discovered UranusAstronomy magazine · astronomy.com
  14. Quantitative reanalysis of Galileo's observations in Sidereus NunciusarXiv · arxiv.org
  15. Galileo, telescopic discoveriesEncyclopaedia Britannica · britannica.com
  16. The Nebra Sky DiskWorld History Encyclopedia · worldhistory.org
  17. Here comes the sun: Stonehenge and the summer solsticeBritish Museum · britishmuseum.org
  18. Antikythera mechanism may be older than thoughtSmithsonian Magazine · smithsonianmag.com
  19. Eratosthenes, Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers entryMacTutor, University of St Andrews · mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk
  20. Lecture 4, Ptolemy and the star catalogueFlorida State University (D. Duke) · people.sc.fsu.edu
  21. Al-Biruni's measurement of the Earth's radiusarXiv · arxiv.org
  22. Copernicus's bookUniversity of Cambridge, Dept. of History and Philosophy of Science · sites.hps.cam.ac.uk
  23. Maragha school and Copernicus, scholarly overviewMcGill University eScholarship · escholarship.mcgill.ca
  24. Kepler biographyMacTutor, University of St Andrews · mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk
  25. Tycho Brahe's observationsUniverse, 10th edition (Macmillan Learning) · digfir-published.macmillanusa.com
  26. This month in astronomical history, July 2022 (Principia)American Astronomical Society · aas.org
  27. IAU vote recommends changing the name of Hubble's lawAstronomy magazine · astronomy.com
  28. Lemaitre's 1927 paper and its 1931 translationarXiv · arxiv.org
  29. History of the cosmic microwave backgroundNASA Goddard · asd.gsfc.nasa.gov
  30. Planck maps the microwave backgroundNASA Science · science.nasa.gov

The text of this chapter is a rewrite and summary of the findings of the sources above and does not replace reading them. Links open external websites.